Welcome to my message board.

New member registration has been disabled due to heavy spammer activity. If you'd like to join the board, please email me at MaxDevore at hotmail dot com.

Dead Reckonings

edited November 2008 in Book Reviews
I have a few items in the fourth issue of Dead Reckonings, including "Dissecting Thomas Harris" (a review of Dissecting Hannibal Lecter: Essays on the Novels of Thomas Harris) and a couple of capsule reviews.




Hedda GablerGNTLGNT

Comments

  • Issue #5:







    Here's the complete TOC, reflecting 94 pages of reviewing goodness:

    • The Vampire as Action-Adventure Anti-Hero ....... June Pulliam

      [Rio Youers, Everdead]
    • A Mask Made of Exposition ..............................Michael Marano

      [Gene Wolfe, An Evil Guest]
    • The Pathetic and the Mundane................................. Kevin Dole

      [Quentin Crisp, Shrike]
    • Mythos and More Mythos ..............................Martin Andersson

      [Richard L. Tierney, The Drums of Chaos; Asamatsu Ken, Queen of K'n-Yan]
    • Forget-Me-Nots? .................................................. Tony Fonseca

      [Ronald Damien Malfi, Passenger; Peter Atkins, Moontown]
    • A New Jungle Book..............................................Hank Wagner

      [Neil Gaiman, The Graveyard Book]
    • Abandon All Preconceptions, Ye Who Enter Here....Sherry Austin

      [Ellen Datlow, ed., Poe]
    • Williams One, Clark Zero ................................... Robert Morrish

      [Simon Clark, Vengeance Child; Conrad Williams, One]
    • Mini-collections from Major Talent.........................Matt Cardin

      [Douglas Smith, Impossibilia; Mark Samuels, Glyphotech and Other Macabre Processes]
    • Ramsey Campbell, Probably: Listing Towards Horror
    • Paralyzed by Discomfort................................... Jack M. Haringa

      [British Invasion, ed. Christopher Golden, Tim Lebbon, and James A. Moore]
    • Passing the Baton ..................................................Ben P. Indick

      [New Dark Voices II, ed. Brian Keene; Jeremy C . Shipp, Sheep and Wolves]
    • Genius Loci ............................................................John Langan

      [Cherie Priest, Fathom]
    • Enter Ghost..............................................................Bev Vincent

      [Stieg Larsson, The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo; David Wroblewski, The Story of Edgar Sawtelle]
    • The Lovecraft Cult......................................................S. T. Joshi

      [Kenneth Hite, Tour de 5 Lovecraft: The Tales; Robert M. Price, Blasphemies & Revelations]
    • Two Unique Visions of Horror..................... Robert Butterfield

      [Scott Nicholson, Scattered Ashes; Tony Richards, Shadows and Other Tales]
    • Living on a Powder Keg..........................................Bev Vincent

      [Joe Hill, Gunpowder]
    • Can You Murder a Dream?...................... John Edgar Browning

      [Jeffrey Ford, The Drowned Life]
    • Doing Your Homework .......................................Hank Wagner

      [F. Paul Wilson, By the Sword]
    • Waking to Nightmares......................................Jack M. Haringa

      [Paul Tremblay, The Little Sleep]
    • The Supernatural in Prose and Verse .......... Donald R. Burleson

      [S. T. Joshi, Emperors of Dreams: Some Notes on Weird Poetry; S. T. Joshi, The Rise and Fall of the Cthulhu Mythos; S. T. Joshi, Classics and Contemporaries: Some Notes on Horror Fiction]
    • The Perfect Museum Edition ......................... Darrell Schweitzer

      [Henry S. Whitehead, Passing of a God and Other Stories]
    • The Weird Scholar ......................................................S. T. Joshi
    • Capsule Reviews.............................................Divers Hands
    Hedda GablerGNTLGNT
  • edited February 2014
    Issue 8 is now out, featuring my review of Dan Simmons' Black Hills


    Dead Reckonings No. 08
    Hedda GablerGNTLGNT
  • edited February 2014
    Issue 12 is now out. I have two pieces in it, a pair of reviews and a dialog with my friend Hank Wagner about two Bradbury novels, which was a lot of fun to do.
    TABLE OF CONTENTS

    Children of Bram and Poesy du Macabre...John Edgar Browning (Stephen Jones, ed., The Mammoth Book of Dracula; Michael A. Arnzen. The Gorelets Omnibus: Collected Poems, 2001–2011.)

    Horror Authors Get Religion...............Kendra Kuss Ditto (Stacia Kane, Sacrificial Magic; Michele Lang, Dark Victory)

    Uttering the Unutterable..................Tony Fonseca (S. T. Joshi, Unutterable Horror: A History of Supernatural Fiction)

    Time and Time Again.....................Antoinette Winstead (Dean Koontz, The Dead Town: A Novel and Odd Apocalypse: An Odd Thomas Novel)

    Weird Poetry, Then and Now...S. T. Joshi (Brett Rutherford, ed., Matthew Gregory Lewis (ed.) Tales of Wonder and Last Flowers: The Romance and Poetry of Edgar Allan Poe & Sarah Helen Whitman; Whippoorwill Road: The Supernatural Poems of Brett Rutherford)

    The Return of the Old-Fashioned Tale of Terror............Robert Butterfield (Scott Thomas, Urn and Willow; William Meikle. Dark Melodies)

    Sweet Zombie Jesus!.........June Pulliam (Daryl Gregory, Raising Stony Mayhall )

    Martin’s Classic Vampire Still Lives.........Braden Dauzat (George R. R. Martin, Fevre Dream.)

    Vampire Sluts, Doppelgangers, and Impossible Abodes.........Javier A. Martinez (Blake Butler. There Is No Year; Grace Krilanovich, The Orange Eats Creeps)

    A Shadow of His Best Work.........Tim Lucas (Tim Burton, dir. Dark Shadows)

    Shelley’s Monster Lives.........Matthew McEver (Mary Shelley, Frankenstein)

    The Heart of Darkness.........Bev Vincent (Peter Straub, The Ballad of Ballard and Sandrine; Graham Joyce, Some Kind of Fairy Tale)

    Ramsey Campbell, Probably: A Can of Heinz

    Love(crafty)an Eccentrics.........Darrell Schweitzer (Peter Cannon, Forever Azathoth: Parodies and Pastiches; W. H. Pugmire, Uncommon Places: A Collection of Exquisites)

    Callers from Hell.........Van Viator (Tom Fletcher, The Leaping and The Thing on the Shore.)

    A Brilliant Idea Poorly Executed.........Jim Rockhill (John C. Tibbetts, The Gothic Imagination.)

    The Wonderful World of Nihilism.........Antoinette Winstead (Dean Koontz, 77 Shadow Street; Adam Nevill, The Ritual.)

    Rekindling Interest in Two Novels.........Tony Fonseca (Ramsey Campbell, The Seven Days of Cain; Graham Masterton, Petrified.)

    Two Views of Two Classics......Hank Wagner, with Bev Vincent (Ray Bradbury, Dandelion Wine and Something Wicked This Way Comes)

    Vampires on Ice......Hank Wagner (Matt Forbeck, Carpathia; Barbara Hambly, The Magistrates of Hell.)

    Lesser Powers?.........Darrell Schweitzer (Tim Powers, The Bible Repairman and Other Stories)

    Of Mirrors and Lakes.........Tony Fonseca (Eric A. Jackson, A Blind Eye to the Rearview; Ronald [Damien] Malfi, Floating Staircase.)

    Werewolf Novel a Real Dog.........June Pulliam (Anne Rice, The Wolf Gift)

    Giron “Classic” Promises, But Doesn’t Deliver.........Andy Trevathan (Sephera Giron, The Birds and the Bees)

    The Weird Scholar............S. T. Joshi

    Notes on Contributors
    Hedda Gabler
  • edited February 2014
    imageIssue 14 is out now. Hank Wagner and I teamed up to talk about The Abominable by Dan Simmons.

    TABLE OF CONTENTS

    Wagner and Vincent on Simmons -- Hank Wagner and Bev Vincent (Dan Simmons, The Abominable)

    Ramsey Campbell, Probably: The Grin Beneath the Flesh

    From Horror to Homage -- Richard Bleiler (J. E. Mooney and Bill Fawcett, eds., Shadows of the New Sun: Stories in Honor of Gene Wolfe; Joseph S. Pulver, Sr., ed. The Grimscribe’s Puppets)

    Joel Lane: In Memoriam -- Robert Butterfield

    Other Realities—Alternate Readings Two Views on Jason V Brock (Jason V Brock, Simulacrum and Other Possible Realities) 

    • Outlier -- Jonathan Johnson
    • Brock as Intriguing New Voice -- Darrell Schweitzer


    Malignant Mothers -- Richard Bleiler (John Boyne, This House Is Haunted, Sophie Hannah, The Orphan Choir)

    What Happens After? -- Sarah Simms (Ellen Datlow and Terri Windling, eds., After: Nineteen Stories of Apocalypse and Dystopia)

    571 Forrester Lane Eats Babies -- Matthew McEver (Sonja Condit, Starter House)

    Triskaidekaphilia -- Jonathan Johnson (Jonathan Thomas, Thirteen Conjurations)

    Submitted: My Stamp of Approval -- Tony Fonseca (Reba Wissner, A Dimension of Sound: The Music of The Twilight Zone)

    Religious Fanaticism Run Amok -- Antoinette Winstead (L. Andrew Cooper, Burning the Middle Ground)

    Fifty Years of Ramsey Campbell -- S. T. Joshi (Ramsey Campbell, Holes for Faces; The Kind Folk; and The Last Revelation of Gla’ak)i

    Two Veteran Storytellers Demonstrate How It Is Done -- Robert Butterfield (Darrell Schweitzer, The Emperor of the Ancient Word; Tony Richards, The Universal and Other Terrors)

    Zombie Scholarship Earns Respect -- June Pulliam (Jennifer Rutherford, Zombies; Aalya Ahmad and Sean Moreland, eds. Fear and Learning: Essays on the Pedagogy of Horror)

    Sequel Deserves to be a Forgotten Chapter -- Braden Dauzat (James Wan, dir. Insidious: Chapter 2)

    Haunted from Within and Without -- Richard Bleiler (Ellen Datlow, ed. Hauntings)

    A Darker Piece of Darkness -- John Edgar Browning (Ellen Datlow, ed. The Best Horror of the Year, Volume 5 andBlood and Other Cravings; Laird Barron, The Beautiful Thing That Awaits Us All and Other Stories)

    The Lovecraftian Magickal Mystery Tour -- Leigh Blackmore (Peter Levenda, The Dark Lord: H. P. Lovecraft, Kenneth Grant and the Typhonian Tradition in Magic)

    A Smorgasbord of Weird -- S. T. Joshi (Lois H. Gresh, ed. Dark Fusions: Where Monsters Lurk!

    Portrait of the Mythos-Maker as a Young Man -- Tony Fonseca (S. T. Joshi, The Assaults of Chaos: A Novel about H. P. Lovecraft)

    Second Time’s the Charm -- Leigh Blackmore (H. P. Lovecraft, The Ancient Track: The Complete Poetical Works)

    Covens, Witchcraft, and Murder, Oh My! ......Antoinette Winstead (Debbie Viguie, The Thirteenth Sacrifice: A Witch Hunt Novel)

    Zombies Are People Too -- June Pulliam (Jonny Campbell, dir., In the Flesh)

    The Weird Scholar -- S. T. Joshi

    Hedda Gabler
  • edited March 2015
    Issue 16 is out now. Hank Wagner and I teamed up twice this time, once to talk about two books recommended by King, and again to discuss the latest two King novels.

    image

    Hedda Gabler
  • edited June 2017
    Issue 21 features a conversation between Hank Wagner and me about Stranger Things

    https://www.hippocampuspress.com/journals/dead-reckonings/dead-reckonings-no.-21

    image

    Bestarred with Fainting Flowers ..... Daniel Pietersen

    Symbolism and Myth in the Work of R. Murray Gilchrist

     

    The “V” Word ..... Jose Cruz

    T. E. Grau, They Don’t Come Home Anymore

     

    Shadows with Teeth ..... Darrell Schweitzer

    Ellen Datlow, ed. The Best Horror of the Year, Volume 8

     

    Existential and Ontological Horror ..... S. T. Joshi

    Joel Lane, This Spectacular Darkness: Critical Essays, ed. Mark Valentine and John Howard

     

    In the Heliotherapy Ward ..... Amber Doll Diaz

    David F. Sandberg, Lights Out

     

    The Horror in the Card Catalog . S. T. Joshi

    Darrell Schweitzer and John Ashmead, ed. Tales from the Miskatonic University Library

     

    Southern Discomfort and the Ubiquitous Undead ..... Stephanie Graves

    Eric Gary Anderson, Taylor Hagood, and Daniel Cross Turner, ed. Undead Souths: The Gothic and Beyond in Southern Literature and Culture

     

    Forever I’m Alone with You ..... Jose Cruz

    Lynda E. Rucker, You’ll Know When You Get There

     

    Stranger Things: A Conversation between Bev Vincent and Hank Wagner

     

    Terrors of the Natural World ..... S. T. Joshi

    Richard Gavin, Sylvan Dread: Tales of Pastoral Darkness

     

    Ramsey’s Rant: Remembering Kirby ..... Ramsey Campbell

     

    Psychosexual Syzygy: Checking in at the Bates Motel ..... Gavin Callaghan

    Bates Motel, Seasons 1 through 5

     

    Terror for Children ..... Taij Devon

    Aric Cushing, Vampire Boy

     

    The Homely Commonplace and the Unimaginably Deranged: J. G. Ballard’s High Rise ..... Alexander Lugo

     

    The Resurgence of Weird Magazines ..... Ashley Dioses

     

    The Final Work of Mark Fisher ..... James Machin

    Mark Fisher, The Weird and the Eerie

     

    SMASH EVERYTHING! Bobby Rhodes and His Demons

    Nathan Chazan

     

    THINKING HORROR: An Exchange with s. j. bagley ..... Alex Houstoun

     

    Pastiches of Pastiches S. T. Joshi

    Brian M. Sammons and Glynn Owen Barrass, ed. The Children of Gla’aki: A Tribute to Ramsey Campbell’s Great Old One

    Hedda Gabler
  • edited November 2017
    Issue 22 is now available. It contains my review (different from the one at CD Online) of Sleeping Beauties.

    Hallowed Readings for Hallowe’en  by  Greg Gbur
    Ellen Datlow and Lisa Morton, ed. Haunted Nights
     
    A Few Reflections by  Martin Andersson
     
    The Creature That Lives in the Dark  by  S. T. Joshi
    Ramsey Campbell, Born to the Dark
     
    Worthy Wordsmithery  by  Tony Fonseca
    Jason V Brock, The Dark Sea Within: Tales & Poems
     
    A Visitor to Arkham  by  Ramsey Campbell
     
    A Journey Beyond All Journeys  by  Donald Sidney-Fryer
     
    Curating Ars Necronomica 2017  by  Brian L. Mullen III
     
    The Wonders of the Visible Weird: Ars Necronomica 2017 and Guest of Honor, John Jude Palencar  by  Dave Felton
     
    An Artist’s Dreamworld Incantation: The Work of John Jude Palencar  by  Michelle Y. Souliere
     
    FOREVER and a Day  by  Jason V Brock
    Darrell Schweitzer, The Threshold of Forever: Essays and Reviews.
     
    The History of the Horror Fiction Boom in the 1970s and ‘80s  by  Stephanie Graves
    Grady Hendrix, Paperbacks from Hell: The Twisted History of ‘70s and ’80s Horror Fiction
     
    Musings: NecronomiCon 2017  by  Alex Smith
     
    In the Wild Beast Wood: The Triad of Mystery in the Artwork of Sidney H. Sime  by  Daniel Pietersen
     
    Horrors of the Everyday Life  by  June Pulliam
    Jordan Peele, dir. Get Out; Brian Falchuck and Ryan Murphy, FX AHS: Cult.
     
    A Century Too Late  by  Tony Fonseca
    Sam Gafford, The Dreamer in Fire and Other Stories
     
    Standing Behind the Curtains A Conversation with T. E. D. Klein  by  Barry Lee Dejasu
     
    Uncanny Age: Joachim Kalka’s Gaslight  by  James Machin
    Joachim Kalka, tr. Isabel Fargo Cole, Gaslight: Lantern Slides from the Nineteenth Century
     
    A Mixed Bag  by  S. T. Joshi
    Justin Steele and Sam Cowan, ed. Looming Low, Volume 1
     
    The Art of NecronomiCon  by  Dean Kuhta
     
    Ghosts, Beyond Metaphor and Psychopathology ... Jim Rockhill
    Zöe Lehmann Imfield, The Victorian Ghost Story and Theology
     
    The Weird and Eerie in Finest Form  by  Daniel Pietersen
    Jeffrey Thomas, Haunted Worlds
     
    Panels of People Screaming: An Interview with Sarah Horrocks ... Nathan Chazan
     
    Vibrant and Vivid: NecronomiCon 2017  by  Elena Tchougounova-Paulson
     
    Nevertheless, She Persisted  by  Bev Vincent
    Stephen King and Owen King, Sleeping Beauties
     
    Thinking Visually: Comments on Comics  by  Alex Houstoun
     
    Revisiting the Dreamlands  by  Darrell Schweitzer
    Kij Johnson, The Dream-Quest of Vellitt Boe
     
    A Reflection: NecronomiCon 2017  by  Dr. Géza A. G. Reilly
    Hedda Gabler
  • Issue 26 is now at the printer. Table of Contents:

    Dead Reckonings No. 23: TABLE OF CONTENTS

    Introduction to Japanese Vampire Fiction ........... Darrell Schweitzer
    Kazuki Sakuraba, A Small Charred Face

    The Coming Singer: Early Critical Responses to Clark Ashton Smith ........... Scott Connors

    Who is Dr. Prozess? ........... S. T. Joshi
    Mark Samuels, The Prozess Manifestations

    Dreams of a Particular Place: Karin Tidbeck’s Jagannath ........... Dr. Géza A. G. Reilly

    Dreams of the House of the Worm: Gary Myers’s Debut Dreamlands Story ........... Nicholas Diak

    Ramsey’s Rant: Honoured by Horror ........... Ramsey Campbell

    Undertow Publications: An Interview with Michael Kelly ........... Daniel Pietersen

    Ghosts and Critics Hand in Hand ........... James Rockhill
    Scott Brewster and Luke Thurston, ed. The Routledge Handbook to the Ghost Story

    Spoken Art: Cadabra Record’s “The Bungalow House” LP ........... Sam Cowan

    Justified Obscurity ........... Ryne Davis
    Seabury Quinn, The Complete Tales of Jules De Gardin: The Horror on the Links—Volume 1

    “I’m sorry. You ate my cat”: A Fond Look at Stranger Things ........... Hank Wagner and Bev Vincent

    James Ulmer: An Exponent of Quiet Horror ........... S. T. Joshi
    James Ulmer, The Fire Doll: Stories

    Visions of the Abyss ........... Christopher Ropes
    Matthew M. Bartlett, The Stay-Awake Men

    Mantid Magazine: An Interview with Farah Rose Smith ........... Alex Houstoun

    Considering an Overlooked Jewel ........... Jason V Brock
    Darrell Schweitzer, Awaiting Strange Gods: Weird and Lovecraftian Fiction

    Drabbles of Dread ........... Dave Felton
    Brandy Yassa, ed. Word Horrors: An Anthology of Horror Drabbles

    The Theory and Practice of Satirical Criticism ........... S. T. Joshi

    Clive Barker: A Boy & His Rawhead, An Analysis of the Story and the Film ........... Randall D. Larson

    A Letter Concerning Things Past ........... Acep Hale
    Der Orchideengarten, ed. Alf Von Czibulka, tr. Helen Grant

    Tested Patience ........... June Pulliam
    Duane Pesice, ed. Test Patterns: Volume 1

    The Banality of Our Bureaucracies ........... Javier Martinez
    Bentley Little, The Handyman

    A Dark, Intense, Fantastic Debut ........... Greg Gbur
    Nadia Bulkin, She Said Destroy: Stories

    About the Contributors
    Hedda Gabler
  • Issue 25

    A Look Behind “The Challenge from Beyond” ........... Michael D. Miller


    Finding the Everything in Nothing ........... Christopher Ropes

    Simon Strantzas, Nothing Is Everything.


    Weird Fiction and Decadence ........... S. T. Joshi

    James Machin, Weird Fiction in Britain 1880–1939.

     

    That Is Not How the Story Goes ........... Bev Vincent

    Theodora Goss, Snow White Learns Witchcraft: Stories and Poems.

     

    Sesqua Valley’s Weirdest Inhabitant, Wilum Pugmire ........... David Barker

     

    Ramsey’s Rant: Horror versus Horror ........... Ramsey Campbell

     

    Marvelous Milicent: The Rise and Removal of a Monster-Artist Maven ........... Danel Olson

    Mallory O’Meara, The Lady from the Black Lagoon: Hollywood Monsters and the Lost Legacy of Milicent Patrick.

     

    Maybe Johnny is an Old One? The Room as Lovecraftian Pastiche ........... Edward Guimont


    Weird Fiction in the 21st Century: A Conversation with S. T. Joshi ........... Alex Houstoun

     

    Rediscovering Ken Greenhall ........... Darrell Schweitzer

    Ken Greenhall, Elizabeth; Hell Hound; and Childgrave.

     

    Some Notes on Call of Cthulhu and Other Lovecraftian Video Games ........... Géza A. G. Reilly

    Call of Cthulhu: The Official Video Game.

     

    Running Towards Nothing: B. Catling’s Vorrh Trilogy ........... Daniel Pietersen

    B. Catling, The Vorrh; The Erstwhile; and The Cloven.

     

    The Horror of Mendacity ........... Acep Hale

    Daniel Powell, Horror Culture in the New Millennium: Digital Dissonance and Technohorror.

     

    Marvelous Monsters ........... Hank Wagner

    Anya Martin, Sleeping with the Monster.

     

    Men Kill Women Like Me ........... Fiona Maeve Geist

    Farah Rose Smith, Anonyma.

     

    Meditations on the Agnostic Gothic ........... Karen Joan Kohoutek

    Hedda Gabler
  • Dead Reckonings No. 32, Fall 2022

    TABLE OF CONTENTS

    Can you Dig It? by Daniel Pietersen
    Being a review of Strange Relics: Stories of Archeology and the Supernatural, 1895-1953
    edited by Amara Thornton and Katy Soar

    A Newly Arrived Triumph by Géza A. G. Reilly
    Being a review of  The Black Maybe: Liminal Tales by Attila Verse, translated by Luca Karafiáth

    June Ruins Everything by June Pulliam
    Being reviews of Westworld, Season 4; The Walking Dead, Season 11; American Horror Stories, Season 2; What We Do in the Shadows, Season 4; Interview with the Vampire, Season 1

    Ramsey's Rant: The Disengaged by Ramsey Campbell 

    The Scandinavian Abyss by Karen Joan Kohoutek
    Being a review of Swedish Cults by Anders Fager, translated by Ian Lemke and Henning Koch

    There are More Things by The joey Zone
    Being a summary of ARS NECRONOMICA 2022, The Visual Divine of the Dark Cosmos, Here and Beyond.

    Necronomicon Providence: It Isn’t Just the Money by Darrell Schweitzer
    Being a report on attending Necronomicon Providence 2022

    Hunter’s Moon Homecoming by CS Schneider
    Being a work of fiction

    A Monstrous World: The Weird Fiction of Frank Belknap Long by Katherine Kerestman
    Being a review of Library of Weird Fiction: Frank Belknap Long edited by S. T. Joshi

    Swordly and Sorcerous Adventures in Atlantis by Darrell Schweitzer
    Being a review of A Sorcerer of Atlantis by John Shirley

    Feeding Nothing to Good Effect by Géza A. G. Reilly
    Being a review of The Envious Nothing: A Collection of Literary Ruin by Curtis M. Lawson

    Ask Leeman: An Interview with the Creator of Ask Lovecraft by Alex Houstoun
    Being an interview with Leeman Kessler

    Tales From The Sticks by The joey Zone
    Being a review of Scrying Stones & Dolmen & Others: Chips & Shavings 1963–1964 by Lee Brown Coye

    “It’s the Beginning of the End”: Stranger Things Season 4 by Hank Wagner and Bev Vincent
    Being a discussion of the latest season of Stranger Things

    Two from the British Library Archives by Karen Joan Kohoutek
    Being a reviews of  The Horned God: Weird Tales of the Great God Pan edited by Michael Wheatley and Spectral Sounds: Unquiet Tales of Acoustic Weird edited by Manon Burz-Labrande

    The World Fantasy Convention New Orleans, November 3–6, 2022 by Darrell Schweitzer
    Being a report on attending the World Fantasy Convention 2022



    Hedda GablerGNTLGNTFlakeNoir
  • Bev! I saw that you had reviewed Stieg Larsson. What is your opinion of his trilogy? i think it was a little overblown. I mean at the time it was praised by so many, so high i was a bit surprised. It was very far from bad but it is in no way a masterpiece. The trilogy, that was actually written by him are good, not great, but the follow ups that his father and brother hired another writer to do was rather horrible i thought. 
    Hedda GablerGNTLGNT
  • I enjoyed the books at the time, but I agree the response was a little over the top. One of my comments about the first book was "The plotting is a little loose and undisciplined, but the novel is engaging and intriguing." 

    For me, it was the beginning of the rise of Scandinavian crime fiction/cinema on the international stage, which I have heartily enjoyed over the years. I never did read the follow-up books, though. Only the original trilogy. I also thought the US remake of the first book was misguided but the original Swedish version was decent enough.
    KurbenHedda GablerGNTLGNTFlakeNoirLou_Sytsma
  • I enjoyed the books at the time, but I agree the response was a little over the top. One of my comments about the first book was "The plotting is a little loose and undisciplined, but the novel is engaging and intriguing." 

    For me, it was the beginning of the rise of Scandinavian crime fiction/cinema on the international stage, which I have heartily enjoyed over the years. I never did read the follow-up books, though. Only the original trilogy. I also thought the US remake of the first book was misguided but the original Swedish version was decent enough.
    Dont bother with the follow ups then. Wasted time. I agree the swedish movies made were ok. Thanks mostly to the actress playing Lisbeth Salander who was really good. The journalist part, Blomkvist, was never as convincing to me.

    I think it must have inspired the quite good Tv series The Bridge heavily. If you havent seen it it can be recommended. 
    GNTLGNTFlakeNoir
  • I have enjoyed The Bridge.
    KurbenHedda GablerGNTLGNTFlakeNoir
Sign In or Register to comment.