Onyx reviews: Against
the Odds by Gwyneth Atlee
The Civil War is over, Lincoln has recently been assassinated, and the
country is putting itself back together. The steamboat Sultana, overloaded with
cargo and malnourished Union soldiers who have been liberated from torturous
conditions in Southern prisons, lumbers up the Mississippi. The fates of three
people aboard the congested boat, each possessing a dark and deadly past, become
Yvette Augeron is fleeing her Southern home to reach her uncle, perhaps the only
remaining family member who will help her. She has been framed for the murder of
her sister and a Union lieutenant and faces death if she stays in New Orleans.
The real murderer, Captain Darien Russell, is also aboard the Sultana,
overseeing the repatriation of the troops. He sees Yvette boarding and, fearing
that she carries evidence of his guilt, resolves that she will not leave the
While stationed in New Orleans, Russell swindled numerous rich Southerners -
Union sympathizers - of their wealth. He hopes his newfound wealth will help him
recover his reputation, tarnished after losing his boys' school when his temper
almost cost the life of a student.
Private Gabriel Davis is thrust between Yvette and Russell. Gabe is traveling
undercover, having been branded a coward and a runaway during battle. Gabe's
family business made the very cannons used so effectively against Southern
soldiers. Seen in action up close, Gabe is appalled by the results of his
family's creations and undergoes a personal crisis on the battlefield.
Try as he might, Gabe cannot escape unseen and it is Yvette who saves him from a
violent confrontation with other soldiers planning to punish Gabe for his
perceived cowardice. Gabe returns the favor shortly after when Yvette encounters
Russell. A growing bond develops between them, the Southern belle and the Union
soldier, an unlikely couple who must learn to see beyond their pre-war
prejudices to survive.
The real-life explosion of the Sultana, a disaster resulting in approximately
1700 deaths, more than were caused by the sinking of the Titanic, casts Yvette,
Gabe and Russell into the murky, dark Mississippi, pitting them against nature
as well as each other. References to the Titanic disaster are not inappropriate
here, as Atlee, the pen name of Woodlands writer Colleen Thompson, writes
numerous scenes of both heroic and despicable acts by desperate people fighting
to save lives—their own or others'—reminiscent of scenes from Titanic.
Against the Odds accurately depicts the personal conflicts of
soldiers and civilians after the end of the war. Old animosities cannot be
quickly overcome and the nightmares of the battlefield follow the soldiers from
both sides as the world around them tries to find a new peace. Atlee has clearly
done her research; the tragic condition of the Union soldiers and their cramped
quarters aboard the Sultana crackle with detail.
Still, this is a romance and, while the ultimate outcome can never be in
question, time and time again Yvette and Gabe's growing attraction is tested and
seemingly doomed. There are instances, though, where they overcome adversity
almost too easily. In one scene, thrust into the river by the Sultana's boiler
explosion, the two find each other in the dark—as the title hints—against
the odds. Even the characters marvel at some of the unlikely coincidences.
Atlee invokes divine provenance to explain these situations; in any other genre
this might be less acceptable, but these two lovers were destined to be together
and no catastrophes, man-made or otherwise, can keep them apart.
Web site and all contents © Copyright Bev Vincent 2007. All rights reserved.