Reviews by title
Reviews by author
Onyx reviews: The City by Dean Koontz
Reviewed by Bev Vincent, 07/24/2014
The City tells the story of a young, black musical prodigy as he
experiences one of the most difficult and pivotal periods in his life during the
tumultuous late 1960s. Jonah Kirk dictates the book nearly fifty years after
these events, so the language is mostly that of an older man rather than a naive
and wide-eyed boy.
Jonah is the grandson of a veteran big band piano player and the son of a nightclub singer, so he
comes by his musical talents naturally. The pregnancy derailed his mother's
university plans. His father abandoned the family shortly after he was born, returned for a brief period and took off again, so his life has
rarely been stable. He and his mother live on the fourth floor of an apartment
complex, where his caregiving is often outsourced to friendly neighbors because
his mother works at a department store in the daytime and at various clubs at
night. After his grandmother dies, they move in with his grandfather.
Though The City starts out seeming like it might be an urban homage to
Something Wicked This Way Comes, it's hard not to see the book as a kind of religious allegory, given Jonah's
first name. The book does have some vague references to the nature of God and to
the spiritual meaning of life, but this isn't the novel's main focus.
The book flirts with the supernatural: certain objects are thought to contain
the talismanic power of juju (or voodoo), there is a character who seems to have
the ability to appear anywhere she wants, even through locked and bolted doors,
though this talent is never explained. There is a pendant given to Jonah by a garrulous
taxi driver, a feather encased in Lucite, that plays an important role in events
late in the book, but once again, the exact nature of this amulet is left vague.
The feather also connects to The Goldfinch, a painting that affects Jonah when
he first sees it in the company of two new friends (the same painting that is
the focus of the recent novel of the same name by
And then there is Miss Pearl, aka "the City," a mysterious
apparition who comes to Jonah both in dreams and in person to bolster his
resolve before and during some of his trials. She's a kind of fairy godmother
crossed with Mary Poppins, but her advice is mostly to stay the course, that
even when things get bad, they always work out for the best. Jonah has dreams
that reveal the past to him (he understands that a friend of his father's
murdered his parents) and seem to reveal the future (although not always). For
the most part, though, the things that happen to Jonah and his friends are the
mundane insults of humanity and the cruelties people inflict upon each other.
It takes a long time for the book to kick into gear, even though it is
composed primarily of four-page chapters meant to make it seem fast-paced. There
is no detectable conflict for dozens of pages of fairly routine domestic drama,
nor is there any antagonist until the alluring but dangerous Fiona Cassidy shows
up, and even then it's not clear why she behaves the way she does. Given what
readers learn about her later, her actions are even harder to understand. At a
certain point, Koontz begins to foreshadow that terrible events are on the
horizon. His approach is not subtle, more or less bashing readers over the head
with heavy-handed references to dire consequences.
Music is central to the story and to Jonah's life. As he tells his story,
Jonah regularly mentions the contemporary music of The Beatles and The Rolling
Stones, though these references often feel awkward and forced. For his part,
nine-year-old Jonah plays the swing music of his mother's and grandfather's era
once he discovers (thanks to "the City") his aptitude for the piano,
but it is rock and roll that will have the biggest impact on his life. Alhough
Jonah is black and the story is set amidst the unrest of the 1960s, race doesn't
play a major part. He effortlessly makes friends with people from all walks of
life and rarely faces any racial issues.
A subplot involving one of Jonah's neighbors, Mr. Yoshioka, a somewhat
retiring Japanese-American tailor who was interned in the Manzanar prison
("relocation") camp during World War II, provides some of the books
more entertaining scenes. Yoshioka becomes a father figure to Jonah, and he also
assembles a posse of former fellow internees to investigate a group of
suspicious, larcenous characters with murderous pasts. The book also contains
the obligatory OCD character in the form of another young musician who lives
across the street from Jonah's grandfather, and a sociopath who pretends to be
part of a violent social Cause but who really just enjoys creating chaos and
believes he's so much smarter than everyone else that he can't possibly be
At the end, readers are back at the beginning, with Jonah Kirk being
encouraged to tell his story by his lifelong friend. Some readers may find
themselves wondering what the point of it all was.
Web site and all contents © Copyright Bev Vincent
2014. All rights reserved.